Home Page
11.16.2004
 Pay per Download P2P? 
CNET today reports that Shawn Fanning's new company, Snocap, is almost ready for launch. Its product is technology that uses audio fingerprinting to identify copyrighted music on file-sharing networks. This would allow the transfer to be blocked, or simply recorded and billed. (A previous story is here.)

Yesterday's WSJ (subscription required) says that Vivendi's Universal Music Group will soon announce a deal to license its content to Snocap, which will then provide back end services for on-line distributors.

Snocap is not the only player in this space. Many content people are interested in Audible Magic, which has comparable technology that it is selling to organizations, such as universities or companies, that want to control P2P.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, which never met a mode of protecting IP that it didn't dislike, snorts that AM technology can be defeated.

But this misses an important point. Any P2P network that added devices specifically designed to defeat content protection of copyrighted material would be dead-duck liable for contributory infringement under Sony, and even Grokster. Such a technology has no non-infringing uses. (And this is true without even looking at the legality of such a program under the DMCA.)

posted by James DeLong : 11/16/2004 11:40:01 AM

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

 

IPcentral WebLog
Blog Main
Recent Posts
  Still More Grokster
Jonathan Zittrain Responds
The Genius of Ray Charles
Encyclopedic Open Source
UN Working Group on Internet Governance
Heritage Foundation on Movies Go to Court
Newspapers
Blogs and the Election
Speaking of New Business Models . . .
Grokster Brief
Archives by Month
  December 2003
January 2004
February 2004
March 2004
April 2004
May 2004
June 2004
July 2004
August 2004
September 2004
October 2004
November 2004
December 2004
Links
  PFF Blog
Atom.xml Site Feed
   
 
Home Page IPcentral Weblog - Intellectual Property and Copyright Commentary
Home Page
11.16.2004
 Pay per Download P2P? 
CNET today reports that Shawn Fanning's new company, Snocap, is almost ready for launch. Its product is technology that uses audio fingerprinting to identify copyrighted music on file-sharing networks. This would allow the transfer to be blocked, or simply recorded and billed. (A previous story is here.)

Yesterday's WSJ (subscription required) says that Vivendi's Universal Music Group will soon announce a deal to license its content to Snocap, which will then provide back end services for on-line distributors.

Snocap is not the only player in this space. Many content people are interested in Audible Magic, which has comparable technology that it is selling to organizations, such as universities or companies, that want to control P2P.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, which never met a mode of protecting IP that it didn't dislike, snorts that AM technology can be defeated.

But this misses an important point. Any P2P network that added devices specifically designed to defeat content protection of copyrighted material would be dead-duck liable for contributory infringement under Sony, and even Grokster. Such a technology has no non-infringing uses. (And this is true without even looking at the legality of such a program under the DMCA.)

posted by James DeLong : 11/16/2004 11:40:01 AM

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

 

IPcentral WebLog
Blog Main
Recent Posts
  Still More Grokster
Jonathan Zittrain Responds
The Genius of Ray Charles
Encyclopedic Open Source
UN Working Group on Internet Governance
Heritage Foundation on Movies Go to Court
Newspapers
Blogs and the Election
Speaking of New Business Models . . .
Grokster Brief
Archives by Month
  December 2003
January 2004
February 2004
March 2004
April 2004
May 2004
June 2004
July 2004
August 2004
September 2004
October 2004
November 2004
December 2004
Links
  PFF Blog
Atom.xml Site Feed
   
 
Home Page